The logic of success 1

The Logic of Success
J.B. suconik

Success in the quest for animals liberation is little more than an alloy of man, ideas and unwavering effort.

If the liberation of animals is to be an extant fact, so must the means and application both of which can materialize via determination. Having put the cart before the horse, and being shy a picture, words (less than a thousand) will attempt to justify this exciting claim.

We are aware that certain events seem always to occur together in a certain sequence. If I strike a wrong key a word will be misspelled, if I remove my glasses I can’t see what I have written, if I forget to wind my old Bulova it will stop running because certain events cause other events. In each instance we take it for granted that events are linked in this way, that a certain group of causes will always result in the same effect. Most people would probably agree that the inanimate universe is in principle mechanistic, that all events in it are mechanically caused, and that scientists will continue to discover more about the way in which these causes operate.
The comparatively new science of psychology aims to explain, and also to predict human behavior which entails the study of psychological chains of cause and effect, however the psychologist is much less able to predict human conduct than other scientists can predict events in the world of the inanimate. We human animals tend to be inscrutable, we act as we do because we are what we are, and we are what we are because of a host of factors: heredity, education, environment, and the whole of our past experience. However, such simplification of a cavernous subject needn’t upset the critical reader because it leads to a point.

Unlike the world of mechanical events in which every event has a set of causes that inevitably produce the same results, the world of human experience does not always produce the same results in every person.

My first exposure to human cruelty of animals had a profound precipitant effect resulting in a different me in the same skin. And one of two salient points is that not everyone exposed to human cruelty of animals will be transformed, (I christen such people as a different breed,) the other point being that only a fly speck of humanity has been exposed to facts similar to those that converted me. I doubt that anything can change those of a 'different breed' but believe that a great conversion is probable via exposure of our collective and corporate cruelty of animals to billions of watchers. They watch a plethora of programs on their computers, and television, technologies constant antidote to ennui that can also spell a new moral and legal status for the animal kingdom.

A TV station featuring a program artfully created to alert the world to the injustice suffered by animals would be the ongoing source of the same causal factors from which the Animal rights movement evolved, and probably be instrumental in the evolvement of the most revolutionary event in the history of the planet, the liberation of the animal kingdom from human tyranny. At least a huge portion of the funds needed now exist in the coffers of organizations dedicated to the betterment of the animal condition, * and the great contingent of people longing for justice for the animal kingdom. To that element I must again indicate that certain occurrences cause, and are caused by certain other occurrences, not only in the physical world but in the world of humans, a world of perpetual change.

*http://www.animalpeoplenews.org/watch-1.html

A Reply to Logic of Success

This is a very interesting post. While it is true that individual human behavior is hard to predict, if only due to natural randomness, it is possible to draw some valid generalizations about mass behavior. This is what economicst, political scientists, social psychologists. and (to a lesser extent) sociologists try to do. I agree it's important to get the message out. I'm not sure TV is the best medium for that purpose, however. TV viewing is an incredibly passive activity, and is in any event controlled my massive corporations that have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo, rather than challenging it. You hear some examples, such as "Ellen" in the gay rights movement, of TV shows helping to push a movement along. But by the time Ellen came out in 1997, I would say the gay rights movement was already well on the way to victory, paved by the intense struggle and bravery of activists in the 1970s, who stood up loudly and proudly for their cause, and challenged homophobic individuals to justify or defend (sometimes violently) their prejudice. This is not to say that mass media will NEVER have value. I certainly do think it will, once their is a sufficiently receptive audience among the masses. But we don't have that, at this point.
	Posted Aug 17, 2007 at 8:06 AM
Suconik replies to the above reply I too am not sure if television is the means to animals liberation, nor do I know that its not the means because nothing in the world of contingent events happens of necessity. I do know that animals are now brutally killed for their flesh and hides, for the thrill of killing, or just because "they are only animals" because the power and will to prevent it does not exist. And I do know that history is a catalogue of events in which people subjected to hellish conditions chose remedial action to put an end to the unacceptable, great risk and cost notwithstanding. I also know that conjecture as to the worth of ideas is inevitable, but not conclusive if not empirically validated. And to assume that there is not "sufficiently receptive audience among the masses" is conjecture, but whether true or false not sufficient reason to abstain from the attempt to glean from such a vast audience a great new faction eager to strive for justice for animals. And how can such power be acquired if not by a medium that commands the attention of billions of watchers? to refuse to utilize such means is to sanction in effect, unabated suffering and violent death of animals because of a lack of confidence in a suggested remedial means. If animals could vote I suspect they would say go for it.

'At least a huge portion of the funds needed now exist in the coffers of organizations dedicated to the betterment of the animal condition,' the details of which are here included for you perusal.

Who Gets the Money? 11th Edition

December 2000

Budgets, Programs, Overhead and Assets--(130 charities)

African Wildlife Foundation AEH $ 6,265,258 $ 4,644,064 $ 1,621,194 26% 26% $ 8,610,803 $ 180,466 $ 6,368,673

Alley Cat Allies AE $ 1,179,476 $ 946,507 $ 232,969 20% 31% $ 1,026,358 $ 28,595 $ 74,296

Alliance of Marine Mammal Parks AE $ 172,759 $ 123,606 $ 49,153 29% 29% $ 79,960 $ (none) $ 79,960

Amer. Anti-Vivisection Society AEV $ 1,088,433 $ 1,012,233 $ 76,200 7% 7% $ 11,264,007 $ 8,971,416 $ 1,072,645 B

American Bird Conservancy AE $ 1,286,543 $ 1,102,103 $ 184,440 14% 14% $ 1,243,250 $ 23,556 4 1,240,528 C

American Humane Association AEW $ 9,224,165 $ 7,419,989 $ 1,804,176 20% 20% $ 10,201,178 $ 2,374,800 $ 4,090,371 D

American SPCA AES $ 31,060,806 $ 22,174,684 $ 8,886,122 29% 36% $ 60,815,984 $ 21,627,410 $ 30,439,147

American Veterinary Medical Assn. $ 17,585,525 $ (breakdown unavailable) $ 25,000,000 (breakdown unavailable) A

American Zoo Association AE $ 3,119,159 $ 2,399,991 $ 719,168 23% 23% $ 7,010,272 $ 259,152 $ 7,334,449

Animal Advocates (Pitts, PA) AES $ 21,753 $ 16,357 $ 5,396 25% 25% $ (breakdown unavailable) A

Animal Concern Ltd. (Scotland) AEV $ 37,589 $ 28,313 $ 9,276 25% 25% $ 3,350 $ (none) $ 3,350 A

Animal Humane Society (MN) S $ 2,656,686 $ 1,949,174 $ 707,512 27% 30% $ 13,925,042 $ 3,991,344 $ 8,250,962

Animal Legal Defense Fund AL $ 2,929,360 $ 1,924,092 $ 1,005,268 34% 62% $ 2,733,872 $ 34,208 $ 2,418,305

ANIMAL PEOPLE P $ 204,717 $ 168,531 $ 36,186 18% 18% $ 24,745 $ 21,759 $ 2,807

Animal Protection Institute AE $ 1,649,605 $ 1,323,154 $ 326,451 20% 28% $ 2,575,615 $ 246,359 $ 2,282,173

Animal Rescue League of Boston S $ 6,455,972 $ 3,782,191 $ 2,673,781 41% 41% $ 115,975,710 $ 3,328,295 $112,226,940 E

Animal Rights International AER $ 59,031 $ 51,108 $ 7,923 13% 13% $ 267,640 $ 799 $ 265,966

Anml Rghts Nwk/Animals' Agenda P $ [Did not respond to requests for IRS Form 990 sent on July 18 and October 20, 2000.]

Animal Welfare Institute AEW $ 1,080,463 $ 958,826 $ 121,637 11% 11% $ 1,451,506 $ 194,618 $ 1,166,880

Ark Trust AE $ 991,566 $ 784,128 $ 207,438 21% 21% $ 976,964 $ 4,409 $ 948,692

Associated Humane Societies S $ 5,019,064 $ 3,317,715 $ 1,701,349 34% 34% $ 14,469,334 $ 1,801,185 $ 13,144,490

Assn. of Vets for Animal Rights AE $ 213,429 $ 166,493 $ 46,936 22% 22% $ 158,015 $ 1,438 $ 160,687

Best Friends Animal Sanctuary SP $ 7,633,763 $ 5,420,237 $ 2,213,526 29% 30% $ 8,620,599 $ 4,699,420 $ 3,776,638

Bide-A-Wee Home Association S $ 6,820,468 $ 5,465,034 $ 1,355,434 20% 26% $ 32,083,600 $ 8,621,242 $ 22,109,518

Born Free Foundation (UK) AES $ 1,990,425 $ 1,432,124 $ 558,301 28% 28% $ 1,483,896 $ 137,697 $ 1,355,193 G

Brooke Hospital for Animals (UK) $ 4,264,464 $ 2,979,966 $ 1,284,498 30% 30% $ 29,213,608 $ 33,887 $ 29,112,894 H

Care For The Wild (UK) AES $ 1,465,981 $ 782,532 $ 683,449 47% 47% $ 1,753,498 $ 56,789 $ 1,771,778 I

Compassionate Crusaders (India) AES $ 6,867 $ 6,424 $ 443 7% 7% $ 76,689 $ 68,950 $ 7,739

Compassion in World Farming (UK) AE $ 453,409 $ 289,775 $ 163,635 36% 36% $ 514,334 $ 19,630 $ 255,566 J

Concern for Helping Animals/Israel $ 237,159 $ 210,036 $ 27,123 11% 11% $ 173,599 $ (none) $ 173,599

Connecticut Humane Society S $ 3,486,939 $ 3,148,474 $ 338,465 10% 11% $ 54,870,998 $ 5,546,887 $ 34,813,674 K

Conservation Fund CH $ 50,068,902 $ 47,188,105 $ 2,880,797 6% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $68,331,753) L

Conservation Interntional AE $ 26,274,524 $ 22,391,576 $ 3,882,948 15% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $83,453,220) L

Cousteau Society AE $ 5,506,959 $ 3,833,646 $ 1,673,313 30% 30% $ 6,083,764 $ 1,329,105 $ 1,051,790 M

Defenders of Wildlife AEH $ 17,132,668 $ 13,632,315 $ 3,500,353 20% 60% $ 14,510,573 $ 608,919 $ 334,842

DELTA Rescue S $ 4,206,100 $ 3,663,580 $ 542,520 13% 25% $ 5,245,935 $ 2,892,223 $ 2,360,295

Denver Dumb Friends League S $ 5,113,696 $ 3,877,787 $ 1,235,909 24% 24% $ 27,310,574 $ 2,077,350 $ 24,919,868 N

Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund Europe $ 955,249 $ 614,611 $ 340,637 36% 36% $ 247,501 $ 61,757 $ 2,010,059 O

Dian Fossey Gorilla Fund Intl. $ 751,525 $ 422,744 $ 273,781 36% 36% $ (breakdown unavailable) O

Dogs' Home Battersea S $ 8,632,641 $ 7,159,011 $ 887,729 10% 10% $ 74,187,261 $ 19,877,549 $ 54,674,333

Doing Things For Animals AE $ 133,350 $ 127,466 $ 5,884 5% 5% $ 38,777 $ (none) $ 50,574 P

Doris Day Animal League AER $ 2,298,227 $ 1,871,894 $ 426,333 19% 58% $ 1,074,851 $ 13,072 $ 1,177,804

Earth Island Institute AE $ 4,216,598 $ 3,674,780 $ 541,818 13% 13% $ 3,058,495 $ 75,523 $ 2,280,697 Q

EarthJustice L $ 13,319,937 $ 9,825,102 $ 3,494,835 26% 36% $ 18,238,665 $ 1,758,918 $ 16,072,649

Elephant Sanctuary in Hohenwald S $ 278,253 $ 236,214 $ 42,039 15% 15% $ 501,523 $ 657,201 $ 263,015

Environmental Defense Fund AE $ 26,311,906 $ 21,235,208 $ 5,076,698 19% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $32,016,597) L

Farm Animal Reform Movement AER $ 254,269 $ 237,796 $ 16,473 6% 6% $ 354,827 $ 7,519 $ 347,575

Farm Sanctuary AES $ 1,500,851 $ 1,116,808 $ 384.043 26% 38% $ 2,743,810 $ 1,573,004 $ 1,010,018 R

Food Animal Concerns Trust AE $ 369,560 $ 264,253 $ 105,307 29% 34% $ 2,042,359 $ 16,577 $ 1,702,038 S

Free Willy/Keiko Foundation AES $ 3,687,811 $ 2,856,733 $ 831,078 23% 23% $ 8,075,915 $ 8,371,559 $ 1,281,078 M

Friends of Animals AER $ 4,289,534 $ 3,768,089 $ 521,445 14% 20% $ 6,986,713 $ 85,025 $ 6,413,439

Fund for Animals AES $ 6,383,888 $ 5,311,129 $ 1,072,759 17% 23% $ 16,219,220 $ 2,156,671 $ 13,817,606

Gorilla Foundation AES $ 1,695,394 $ 1,044,644 $ 650,750 38% 38% $ 3,450,987 $ 957,538 $ 262,569

Greenpeace Inc AE $ 13,552,730 $ 7,742,106 $ 5,810,624 43% 54% $ 2,853,309 $ 411,706 $ 1,267,964 T

Greenpeace Fund Inc. AE $ 9,838,622 $ 8,072,228 $ 1,766,394 18% 18% $ 11,411,088 $ (none) $ 5,783,302 T

Hearts United for Animals (NE) S $ 127,353 $ 110,322 $ 23,031 18% 18% $ 49,230 $ 42,607 $ 35,035

Holiday Humane Society (CA) S $ 390,923 $ 354,515 $ 36,408 9% 9% $ 14,452,402 $ 1,399,979 $ 13,572,021 U

Home for Life (MN) S $ 141,363 $ 118,817 $ 22,546 16% 16% $ 4,502 $ 324,716 $ 2,169 V

Humana Reserve (CA) S $ 15,368 $ 14,986 $ 382 3% 3% $ 5,250 $ (none) $ 3,996

Humane Farming Association AES $ 1,412,290 $ 1,227,026 $ 185,264 13% 22% $ 4,894,145 $ 2,396,234 $ 2,522,579

Humane Society of Indianapolis S $ 1,975,940 $ 1,335,137 $ 640,803 32% 32% $ 11,123,805 $ 3,602,653 $ 7,688,487

Humane Society of the U.S. AEW $ 51,680,147 $ 29,746,546 $ 16,499,035 32% 45% $ 99,412,194 $ 8,848,034 $ 95,258,400 W

In Defense of Animals AER $ 1,707,270 $ 1,390,001 $ 317,269 19% 42% $ 669,696 $ 100,521 $ 549,66

Intl. Fund for Animal Welfare AE $ 12,742,725 $ 9,298,483 $ 3,444,242 27% 41% $ 12,288,371 $ 1,819,246 $ 11,241,92 X

IFAW Charitable Trust (U.K.) AE $ 853,140 $ 750,707 $ 102,434 12% 30% $ 1,224,248 $ 3,396 $ 1,230,593 X

IFAW (all affiliates combined) AE $ 56,291,000 $ 41,373,885 $ 14,917,115 27% 27% $ 36,117,000 $ 2,405,000 $ 31,045,000 X

Intl. Primate Protection Lg. ES $ 562,283 $ 413,709 $ 148,574 26% 26% $ 1,737,415 $ 327,148 $ 1,382,636 Y

Intl. Soc. for Animal Rights AE $ [Did not respond to requests for IRS Form 990 sent on July 18 and October 20, 2000.]

Intl. Wildlife Coalition AE $ [Did not respond to requests for IRS Form 990 sent on July 18 and October 20, 2000.]

International Wolf Center (MN) S $ 1,190,552 $ 773,859 $ 416,693 35% $ 1,005,469 (breakdown unavailable) A

Jane Goodall Institute ES $ 2,095,087 $ 1,645,112 $ 449,975 21% 21% $ 6,136,947 $ 60,323 $ 2,497,612

Jiv Daya Resource Center P $ 3,455 $ 3,455 $ (none) 0% 0% $ 7,990 $ (none) $ 7,990 A

Last Chance for Animals AER $ 657,946 $ 441,895 $ 216,051 33% 33% $ 426,133 $ 41,016 $ 383,315

Living Free (CA) S $ [Did not respond to requests for IRS Form 990 sent on July 18 and October 20, 2000.]

Massachusetts SPCA AES $ 34,806,314 $ 29,094,346 $ 5,711,968 16% 18% $ 90,130,035 $ 22,762,158 $ 77,234,914 Z

Natl. Anti-Vivisection Society V $ 2,153,309 $ 1,535,661 $ 617,648 29% 50% $ 7,655,366 $ 20,008 $ 7,691,013

National Audubon Society AE $ 53,572,777 $ 44,835,821 $ 8,736,956 16% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $64,674,507) L

Natl. Canine Defense Lg. (UK) SAE $ 23,337,940 $ 15,839,720 $ 7,498,220 32% 32% $ 64,102,560 $ 8,733,260 $ 34,476,000 A

Natl. Fish & Wildlife Fndtn. AEH $ 40,225,923 $ 38,264,757 $ 1,961,166 5% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $47,138,948) L

Natl. Humane Education Society S $ 7,246,722 $ 4,331,373 $ 2,915,349 40% 79% $ 3,362,134 $ 1,920,276 $ 1,052,281 AA

National Wildlife Federation AEH $ 87,043,571 $ 75,421,381 $ 11,622,190 13% 23% $ 103,410,391 $ 27,034,241 $ 88,561,918 BB

Natural Resources Defense Cncl AEH $ 30,564,970 $ 24,979,301 $ 5,585,669 18% 36% $ 53,512,861 $ 9,832,552 $ 46,045,282

Nature Conservancy CH $359,426,739 $285,001,582 $115,337,669 32% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $704,004,760) L

New England Anti-Viv. Soc. AEV $ 1,052,240 $ 643,263, $ 408,977 39% 39% $ 10,054,883 $ 416,362 $ 9,682,965 CC

New Zealand Anti-Viv. Society V $ 18,698 $ 10,601 $ 8,097 43% 43% $ 13,543 $ (not clear) $ 13,543

North Shore Animal Lg. America SAE $ 33,084,848 $ 25,234,647 $ 7,850,201 24% 41% $ 54,875,051 $ 12,573,131 $ 37,845,397 P

Ocean Mammal Institute $ 75,870 $ 67,868 $ 8,002 11% 35% $ 40,109 $ (none) $ 40,109 DD

Owens Fndtn. for Wildlife Cons. $ 296,383 $ 242,106 $ 54,277 18% 18% $ 1,101,414 $ 924,243 $ 176,294

People For Animals (Calcutta) AE $ 24,126 $ 23,845 $ 281 1% 1% $ 75,049 $ 69,524 $ 5,524

PETA AER $ 16,487,851 $ 14,417,787 $ 2,070,064 13% 44% $ 5,909,780 $ 416,526 $ 3,240,304 EE

Peregrine Foundation SH $ 4,847,214 $ 4,637,849 $ 209,365 5% 5% $ 16,830,496 $ 7,808,724 $ 6,898,298 FF

Performing Animal Welfare Soc. AES $ 1,470,436 $ 1,212,435 $ 258,001 18% 37% $ 1,523,255 $ 2,872,079 $ 401,211

Pet Savers Foundation S $ 2,586,604 $ 1,616,919 $ 969,685 38% 38% $ 2,338,181 $ 16,240 $ 834,550 P

PETsMART Charities $ 7,771,882 $ 6,611,027 $ 1,160,855 15% 15% $ 3,251,606 (breakdown unavailable) A

Phys. Comm. for Resp. Medicine AEV $ [Did not respond to requests for IRS Form 990 sent on July 18 and October 20, 2000.]

Pig Hoppers (MI) S $ 27,343 $ 19,329 $ 8,016 29% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $28,587.) A

Primarily Primates S $ 836,038 $ 589,147 $ 246,891 30% 30% $ 2,191,443 $ 2,331,126 $ 148,400

Progressive Anml Welf. Soc (WA) S $ 2,327,754 $ 1,830,971 $ 496,783 22% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $2,624,617.) A

Project Equus AE $ 19,625 $ 14,219 $ 5,406 28% 28% $ 3,190 $ 3,175 $ 15

PsyETA AE $ 100,458 $ 76,386 $ 23,072 23% 23% $ 23,039 $ 3,078 $ 19,321 GG

Rainforest Action Network AE $ 3,156,731 $ 2,207,657 $ 949,074 30% 35% $ 613,341 $ 129,050 $ 805,456

Rashtriya Ahinsa Pratish. (India) $ 3,077 $ 2,323 $ 754 25% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $2,424.) A

Royal SPCA (UK) S $105,084,640 $ 74,989,000 $ 30,095,800 29% 29% $ 286,774,960 $105,298,780 $196,502,500

Royal S.P. Birds (UK) S $ 69,573,920 $ 57,341,380 $ 12,232,540 17% 17% $ 34,484,840 $ 17,122,900 $ 24,123,120

San Francisco SPCA SAE $ 10,429,905 $ 9,400,084 $ 1,029,821 10% 10% $ 50,550,169 $ 16,657,245 $ 34,360,850

Save The Animals Fndtn. (OH) S $ 347,154 $ 342,383 $ 4,771 1% 8% $ 281,492 $ 310,000 $ 172,995 HH

Sea Shepherd Conservation Soc AE $ 431,445 $ 303,320 $ 128,125 30% 30% $ 3,544,696 $ 2,799,459 $ 230,514 II

SHARK AE $ 73,923 $ 70,422 $ 3,501 5% 5% $ 17,343 $ 9,266 $ 4,341

Sierra Club AE $ 54,295,207 $ 46,717,411 $ 7,577,796 14% 14% $ 31,127,927 $ 4,312,587 $ 31,642,802

SPA de Lyon et Sud Est (Fr.) AES $ 3,010,927 $ 2,252,619 $ 925,196 31% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $2,716,721.) A

SPA Abroad (was SPANA) (UK) S $ 3,173,500 $ 2,393,926 $ 779,574 25% 25% $ 11,198,704 $ 111,286 $ 11,087,417

SPCA of Texas S $ 4,297,956 $ 2,492,814 $ 1,805,142 42% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $4,505,351.) A

SUPRESS/The Nature of Wellness AEV $ 370,770 $ 280,065 $ 90,705 25% 25% $ 180,786 $ 12,405 $ 160,714

Tiger Haven (TN) S $ 95,266 $ 88,279 $ 6,988 7% notes $ 607,316 $ 601,640 $ 7,207 JJ

Tony LaRussa's ARF (CA) S $ 2,194,180 $ 1,177,330 $ 1,016,850 46% 46% $ 3,666,016 $ 3,428,826 $ 371,573 KK

Trust for Public Land C $ 51,413,434 $ 45,476,223 $ 5,937,211 12% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $95,009,203) L

Turpentine Creek Foundation S $ 362,409 $ 362,409 $ (none) 0% 23% $ 507,765 $ 944,748 $ 6,842 LL

United Animal Nations AE $ 791,566 $ 598,914 $ 192,652 24% 38% $ 535,034 $ 38,275 $ 498,409

United Poultry Concerns AE $ 111,226 $ 80,005 $ 31,221 28% 28% $ 128,727 $ 99,202 $ 60,915

Univ, Fed. for Animal Welf. (UK) $ 970,959 $ 707,202 $ 263,757 28% 28% $ 5,260,213 $ 776,171 $ 4,718,787

VivVegie Society AE $ 34,321 $ 34,321 $ 13,977 40% 30% $ 5,814 $ (Breakdown unavailable.)

WARDS Inc. AE $ 240,681 $ 163,995 $ 76,686 32% 32% $ 578,618 $ 245,769 $ 335,817

Wild Animal Orphanage S $ 314,670 $ 276,664 $ 38,012 12% 12% $ 613,208 $ 713,795 $ 14,507

Wild Burro Rescue S $ 116,067 $ 99,237 $ 16,830 15% 15% $ 122,951 $ 37,539 $ 85,412 MM

Wildlife Conservation Society AES $ 94,895,366 $ 81,885,429 $ 13,009,937 14% 14% $ 314,478,744 $138,727,899 $210,602,426 NN

Wildlife Waystation S $ 2,158,656 $ 1,546,225 $ 612,431 28% 28% $ 2,068,120 $ 1,505,551 $ 527,119

WSPA (U.S.) AES $ 9,096,686 $ 6,290,929 $ 2,805,757 31% 31% $ 6,040,494 $ 439,299 $ 3,926,232

WSPA (British Section) AES $ 6,118,760 $ 4,717,720 $ 1,401,040 23% 23% $ 1,236,700 $ 217,460 $ 1,281,520

World Wildlife Fund (U.S.) AEH $ 89,732,867 $ 78,621,744 $ 11,111,123 12% (Assets unavailable; 1999 income of $111,262,567) L

World Wildlife Fund (U.K.) AEH $ 39,647,440 $ 30,366,380 $ 9,281,060 23% 23% $ 14,817,160 $ 1,230,060 $ 19,795,500

Notes on budgets and assets	Individual Compensation of Executives et al
Opposition Groups	Executive Compensation Notes